There are countless reasons to love the Emmy-nominated series Blue Bloods, and one of the most compelling is undoubtedly its rich array of characters. With over 200 episodes, the CBS crime drama continually captivates viewers with its intriguing personas, making it tough to choose a single fan favorite. While the Reagan family—Commissioner Frank Reagan (Tom Selleck) and ADA Erin Reagan (Bridget Moynahan)—clearly hold a special place in fans’ hearts, other characters have also made a significant impact.
Detective Anthony Abetemarco (Steve Schirripa) has won over many viewers with his charismatic presence, and fans have expressed a desire for more screen time for Detective Abby Baker (Abigail Hawk). The show’s appeal extends to recurring characters as well, with many delighted by the return of Jack Boyle (Peter Hermann) in Season 13.
However, one character that many fans miss is Sergeant Anthony Renzulli, portrayed by Nick Turturro. Renzulli, who was last seen in Season 6, Episode 12 (“Cursed”), left a noticeable void for some viewers. On Reddit, u/sevenpastzeero expressed nostalgia for Renzulli, suggesting that the character could return as a captain of the precinct. This sentiment was echoed by other fans, including u/JerseyJedi, who wished for a guest appearance, and u/LennyMcCartney65, who would love to see Renzulli back.
Turturro, who played Renzulli with notable enthusiasm, had previously hinted at his interest in a spinoff in a 2013 tweet. On his podcast Breaking Bread with Nick Turturro, he mentioned that his departure was partly due to feeling creatively stale after a long tenure on the show, a sentiment he also experienced on NYPD Blue. Additionally, Turturro’s busy schedule, filled with a variety of roles across film and television, contributed to his exit from Blue Bloods. Despite his departure, his portrayal of Sergeant Anthony Renzulli remains a memorable part of the series.
